Ep #300: Behind Closed Doors Part 3: What No One Tells You About Titles and Impact
Ready to stop letting titles define your leadership journey?
I see more and more women questioning whether the next promotion or paycheck is actually the goal—or just one piece of a much bigger picture. That shift matters, especially as your influence, scope, and expectations grow.
In this 300th episode of Women Changing Leadership, I’m sharing candid insights from conversations inside my Leadership Table Mastermind about what executive advancement really looks like today. We talk honestly about why promotions still matter, why they can feel surprisingly underwhelming when you get them, and how focusing only on titles can limit your impact.
This is a grounded look at the difference between climbing the corporate ladder and positioning yourself for meaningful influence. I break down how to advocate for executive roles on your own terms—and why owning your voice often matters more than the title itself.
If you’re rethinking your goals and want a clearer way to define success that actually fits the leader you’re becoming, this episode will help you reset the frame.
Let’s get started.
What You'll Learn:
- Why women’s professional goals are evolving beyond titles and paychecks
- The difference between seeking impact and simply climbing the corporate ladder
- The real reasons promotions both matter—and don’t
- How to position yourself for executive roles on your own terms
- How leaders inside the Leadership Table Mastermind are redefining success in today’s workplace
Listen to the Full Episode:
Featured on the Show:
- Want More? If you’re ready to go beyond the podcast—maybe join that secret society of inspiring leaders—book a free discovery call with me to talk about what it would look like for you to get a seat at the Leadership Table.
- Ep #298: Behind Closed Doors Part 1: The Career Advice You Need to Rethink in 2026
- Ep #299: Behind Closed Doors Part 2: What No One Admits About Women and Promotions
Full Transcript
Stacy Mayer (00:01.016)
Hello corporate badasses, welcome to another episode of Women Changing Leadership. I am your host, Stacey Mayer, and super excited as always to be here with you again this week. We had a really great conversation last week inside of my leadership table mastermind, and this is a secret society of women leaders where we get together throughout the month.
and we have conversations about what's going on for us in leadership, and then I help guide them one-on-one through coaching as well. And this is just an absolutely extraordinary group of women, and what I really appreciate about this group is that we always have real conversations. We cut through the BS. So because this was our first conversation last week of the new year,
naturally we kind of got around to goals and what we hope to accomplish in 2026. And I noticed that a couple of the women in the group were very silent, didn't really want to speak out loud. And I think that's normal because if you're having a conversation about goals, but you're not really sure what your goals are or exactly how you want to articulate them, then of course you're going to keep quiet and listen and see what you can absorb.
But the really nice turn of events that this conversation took is very quickly we all realized collectively that our goals were quite different this year than they had been in the past. And so I wanna give you a quick example before I get into today's episode, which by the way is the third part of my Behind Closed Doors series where I talk to you about the real secrets to having success at executive leadership.
The interesting turn of events, as in they're setting their goals differently, looked a little bit like this. Like the last time that I was looking for a job, I was really focused on title, right? So these are the converse, these are their words, right? So the last time or last year when I started 2025, I was really focused on getting a new role or getting a promotion, but it was really...
Stacy Mayer (02:17.122)
focused more so on, wanna become a senior vice president or I wanna become a CBO or a CFO or something like that, right? So really focused on getting that next title, right? And what we were noticing collectively, and I'm saying collectively because including myself, obviously I'm the leader of this group and of all of these women, but this is definitely the same exact place that I'm at is that...
You know, in the past for me, my goals have always been focused on the number of clients that I want to serve and the number of like the numbers of business. And this year I'm feeling very different. And essentially what that looks like is that we're looking at the year as a whole and we're saying, okay, when December of 2026 comes around, what is it that I want to have accomplished? Like what is it that I'm going to feel most proud of? And so we're still stretching ourselves.
We're not giving up on our goals of having a higher title or in my case, having and serving more clients this year and getting more women their voice at the table. But instead what we're doing is we're sort of reframing that a little bit. And that reframe is actually what goes into today's episode, today's behind the scenes episode. This idea that promotions and titles matter and they also don't matter.
So I'm gonna continue on this story of, in the past in 2025, I was really focused on titles. And so then how do you go into 2026 and no longer be focused on titles, but still have the expectation that you're going to get the title? Now, this is really important for you to hear because as these women are saying, my goals are less focused on title. They're not saying I'm not going to get the title.
Instead, what they're saying is, know in my next role, I'm going to be head of the finance department, or I'm going to be head of business development, or whatever that might be for themselves. And they know that's going to be true. And so as they're going into their promotion conversations or their interviews, they're having conversations about the impact that they're going to make, right? They're actually listening and talking to the people who are interviewing them about the
Stacy Mayer (04:36.842)
impact that they want to make, the outcomes of their work. And of course, they're going to have the higher title and salary that comes with us. And this is part of the evolution of a woman leader, right? So when you, as you continue to evolve and as women, you know, inside of this mastermind, a lot of these women have been working with me for three, four, five years and they have evolved over time where
At some point it's enough to say, hey, I need a title, right? My next promotion is XYZ title and that's what I deserve because prior to that you hadn't even been claiming that you deserved a higher level title, right? You weren't directly asking for it, but at some point you know that that title is inevitable and you're only interviewing for roles that would treat you and include you at the highest level. So that's where these women are at. And I found that to be
quite fascinating in terms of conversation and goal setting and how we're thinking about goals. And I get really, really excited about what all of these women are going to be able to accomplish in the coming year. And I can't wait to share with you my journey, their journey, and are we able to do it even more so, it as in get promoted, have, you know, higher titles, recognition, impact.
on our own terms, right? And I think that's really how it starts to be on our own terms is when we look at the entire promotion process differently. And it's not just about the titles, but it's about really wanting to make sure that, yes, I have that voice at the table and people are actually listening to me and I'm actually being included in these conversations. Now, if you're a woman leader that wants to serve yourself and your organization at the highest level,
then I invite you to join us inside of the Leadership Table Mastermind. As I said, it's an invitation only program and you might have to work with me a little tiny bit. I have a really amazing two month crash course program where we work together, solve a big problem in a short amount of time, basically get you over the hurdle so that you can have these deeper, higher level conversations with this most fascinating, amazing group of women.
Stacy Mayer (06:50.806)
If that's of interest to you, then go to www.StacyMayer.com/Apply and book a free discovery call with me personally where we'll walk through what your roadmap to success, what your personal evolution of a woman leader is going to look like over the next three, four, five years. And I would absolutely love to help you get there. So go to www.StacyMayer.com/Apply and then we'll hop on the phone in the next couple of weeks and we'll chat about it. It's gonna be amazing.
I can't wait to see what 2026 brings for you as well. All right, so getting into this idea of behind closed doors and part three of today's episode. And if you haven't listened to the other two parts, then I encourage you to go back and after you listen to this podcast episode, because we had really great conversations around what it actually takes, like what.
what your boss is saying versus what they're actually doing and how you can begin to do more of what they're doing versus what they're saying. And then in last week's episode, we had a really fantastic conversation about women in leadership and how some women's leadership programs are not actually leading women in a way that is really helpful and beneficial to their own career success. And then today's episode, I'm talking about why promotions matter and also
quite frankly, why they don't matter. So one thing that, you know, nobody's gonna tell you, literally, because this is behind closed doors, nobody's gonna tell you that when you finally get your promotion, when you finally get that huge pay rate, well, the pay raise is actually, you do feel it, right? But when you finally get that promotion, right? That you're not gonna care, right? And this is really funny.
But one of the greatest compliments that I get from my clients is that they got their promotion and they were like, what's next? Can you imagine? You've been wanting this promotion or this title or you've been trying to become a vice president for a long time. Or let's say you're on the job search and you really want a new role and you need to start working as soon as possible. When you get that title, if you do it the way that I teach,
Stacy Mayer (09:12.366)
the actual outcome is gonna be, what's next? Like let that sink in. Does that feel disappointing to you? Does that feel a little bit frustrating? Maybe it's just confusing, like how is that possible? If you're listening to this and you're like, yeah, exactly, that's exactly how I felt, then you know what I'm talking about. So essentially, your boss, your boss's boss,
want you to believe that your promotion is literally everything that matters. Okay? That your promotion is literally like everything that matters. Like, don't worry about the promotion or when the promotion comes, it's gonna come. Like the promotion's great or like whatever noise is coming out of their mouth is irrelevant. But essentially what they're saying to you,
is I will reward you or if you do this work, you will be rewarded, right? And again, know, bonuses, higher pay increases, those are all incredibly valuable and I would not say that anybody box at that, right? Like that's huge. But for a lot of women who are working and they're operating in that authentically powerful way and they're really showing up like one or two levels ahead all the time.
Essentially what a promotion does for them is level set what they were already doing. Right? I had another woman who emailed me a client who had been operating as a senior director for quite some time and they gave her the senior director title. Finally, just like out of nowhere actually was just, it was the thing that we all dream of. It's like, go to your performance review and they're like, Hey, here's a title to go along with that and a pay increase. Now the pay increase is great, but the title, she was like,
Meaning, I've been doing this job for a long time. What's next? And she's already been thinking about what it's gonna take to become a vice president. She's been building her team, she's been building her network in a way that really sets her up to become a vice president. So this guy gives her the stamp of approval and says, hey, you've arrived. This is amazing. I'm making you a senior director. You're like, okay, great, thank you. You're very, very grateful, but.
Stacy Mayer (11:33.43)
you know that promotions also don't matter, right? So at the end of the day, it's about the impact that you're able to make. It's can you continuously grow? Are you making the professional difference that you wanna be making at your organization? And so I want you to kind of think about this because I think it's funny and it also will help direct you and guide you if you know that your next promotion is just the beginning.
of something even bigger than what you're supposed to be able to accomplish. This is incredibly motivating for my clients because, know, when we get so fixated on this like really kind of small goal, imagine if my client was like senior director was the end all be all. And she was like, my God, I finally got promoted to senior director. And for those of you who have been trying to get promoted to senior director for a long time, I'm not making fun of you, but I want you to see the
the silliness of this, which you probably already see, like at the end of the day, you know, at the end of our life, you know, by the time we get to retirement, we're not going to be like, I finally made it to senior director and that was my life's calling. No, it's about the impact that you're able to make. Okay. And so there is this idea that promotions don't really matter. Now I'm going to get into why promotions really matter. Okay. So
behind the scenes is the words that are coming out of your boss's mouth is that, you know, we'll get your title, you'll get your pay increase, you'll get that promotion, and then it'll all be worth it. And then you're sort of like, I'm kind of reading the writing on the wall. I don't think anything really changes. But here's the place where the promotions do actually matter. And this again is also what they're not going to tell you, is that if you're
Let's say you're not at that vice president level, or let's say that you're not at that C-suite level, and you're not going to be seen in the same way as you are at the director level, right? Like let's say you reach out to a customer, let's say you reach, you're trying to build your team, you're trying to get more money to grow, right? You're trying to be included in these management team conversations. Based strictly on your title, you're not going to be included, right?
Stacy Mayer (13:55.872)
A lot of women find themselves not even being able to schedule meetings with higher level executives because they don't have the title. Now, if you work with me, I'll give you a roundabout way that you can get included anyway. But for the most part, customers, everybody, like hierarchy, you might have that peer that looks at you sideways whenever you reach out to them. It's because of your title.
Right? You can have the most authority in the world. You can be working on the biggest, most high profile project, but people aren't gonna call you back unless you're actually at the C-suite, unless you're actually reporting directly to the CEO, whatever that might be that gives you that level of authority. And so in these particular cases, title does matter.
Right. And so, you know, sometimes people will tell you this, they'll be like, well, you know, this room is only for vice presidents. And so then you're like, even though I'm working on the highest profile project at the company, I can't even go to this meeting because I'm not a VP. Right. And so I want you to become a VP. I want your title to matter so that you can actually be included in those conversations. Right. Like from the get go. And so this is the place where titles really do.
matter and I think it's very important as you're having promotion conversations that you still have conversations about title but you also don't make a title like show your own personal value like you don't make it mean anything about yourself if this makes sense okay I hope you're following along because even just knowing this as you continue to move forward
on your career development, hopefully is gonna motivate you to go for more bigger, like I said, most of the time when my clients are getting promoted, they're already operating like two levels above themselves. And so it just is like kind of like, well, finally, right? I have women all the time, like even in my leadership table mastermind, we only have one criteria to be inside of the leadership table mastermind. And that is that idea that you are
Stacy Mayer (16:06.35)
personally, authentically powerful. And what makes an authentically powerful woman is a woman who takes ownership of her career path, who is having those higher level conversations, who is willing to push the envelope. But also, just as I said, you know, we're having those deeper level conversations where we're saying, hey, this year I redefined my goals. But when you're redefining your goals and you're saying, hey, I just want to make a bigger impact at my next role,
or I wanna make a bigger impact in my current role, that's also operating from that place that I deserve a promotion. I need the title and the pay that matches that impact and you're willing to ask for it, right? So that's the criteria of the leadership table mastermind anyway. That's the definition of an authentically powerful woman is that we're being very realistic and we're understanding that titles matter and they also don't matter at all.
At the end of the day, who cares if you made it to senior director? What I care about is how are you operating? And so part of the reason that I was sharing this with you is that there's a lot of women in the group that are at that director level. And I have women that are in high level individual contributor roles. have no direct reports, but when we're having this conversation inside this, combined with women in the C suite who have a hundred direct reports, right? So when we're having these conversations though,
that woman who has no direct reports and the woman who has 100, they sound exactly the same, right? We are very empowered. We're making decisions in that higher level leadership way. And we're asking for more in the way that is authentically powerful to ourselves, if that makes sense, right? So you wanna make sure that as you're going through your career journey, that you're kind of like weighing both sides, you know.
pros and cons and like, is it that I'm asking for at this time? What is it I'm asking for at this time? It's a lot easier if you have a coach in your back pocket like me, but if you don't have one, you have this podcast and just start to begin to ask yourself these questions. Now, the other thing that I wanna point out is as you begin to get promoted, as you begin to get into those higher level positions, it doesn't always equal impact, right? So I have women.
Stacy Mayer (18:28.202)
inside of the mastermind who are operating at the C-suite, who have C-suite level titles and are still being pushed out, right? Who are still being talked over at meetings, who are still being not included in conversations. And so if you think title is the only thing that matters and that once you get the title, then you'll have the impact, no, you have to figure out how to include yourself at all levels.
You have to figure out and know beyond a shadow of doubt that your voice matters, that it needs to be included in these conversations. And then you have to be able to tweak what it is that you're saying and doing accordingly so that you continue to manage your career. This is also what it means to maximize your career, to get the most out of your career. It's not the most hours. It could definitely be the most pay. It could definitely be the most title.
But ultimately it's the most impact, right? It's the most influence because that is your birthright. You deserve to be in that room. Why not you? We need your voice at the leadership table. And when you begin to believe that, hey, I'm gonna raise my hand for this title. And I also know that when I get this title, that it's not the end all be all and I'm always growing and I'm always evolving and I'm always moving and.
challenging myself to get to that next level, next level, next level and beyond. Thank you all so, so much for listening to the series. I hope it was useful. Here I am a woman who has coached over hundreds of women to not only get themselves into those higher level leadership positions, but also to be successful, to sit at that leadership table and to continuously, continuously grow. This is the type of executive coaching that I do.
And I would love, love, love to welcome you into that next level of my programming. So if this podcast has been useful to you, I strongly encourage you to sign up for a call with me, www.StacyMayer.com/Apply so that we can figure out what that next evolution, what that next level of leadership is going to look like for you. Thank you all so, so much for listening and I'll see you next week. Bye.

About Your Host
Hi! I'm Stacy Mayer, a Certified Executive Coach and Promotion Strategist on a mission to bring more diversity to the leadership table by getting 1000 underrepresented corporate managers promoted into senior executive positions each year worldwide.
I help undervalued executives scale to the C-Suite using repositioning strategies that build your confidence and visibility, so you can earn the recognition and support you need from key stakeholders while embodying your unique leadership style.
My podcast “Women Changing Leadership with Stacy Mayer” tackles topics like executive communication, getting more respect in the workplace from challenging bosses and team members, and avoiding the common mistakes that sabotage career advancement.
Enjoy the Show?
- Don’t miss an episode: follow the show on Spotify and subscribe via Apple Podcasts or YouTube.
- Leave a review in Apple Podcasts.
- Share with your friends on social media by clicking the links below.





