Ep #275: Why I Didn’t Hire Them (Even If the Interview Went Great)

Have you ever walked out of an interview thinking, “That went amazing!”…

…only to never hear back?

Or maybe you were this close to landing a role and couldn’t figure out why it didn’t work out?

Well, I recently spent several days reviewing 30+ applications and interviewing candidates for a contract role on Team Badass—and what I saw confirmed a lot of what I’ve been coaching you to do all along.

Some people absolutely stood out. Others missed the mark entirely.

So in this episode, I’m sharing what worked, what didn’t, and how the strongest applicants presented themselves in a way that felt clear, aligned, and easy to say yes to.

You’ll hear the real reasons certain people moved forward—and why others didn’t—even when we had amazing conversations. I’ll also share what surprised me, what turned me off instantly, and how the follow-up made a bigger difference than most people realize.

This episode of Women Changing Leadership with Stacy Mayer is packed with real examples from my own hiring process so you can feel more confident and strategic the next time you put yourself out there.

Let’s go.

Want to receive the recognition you deserve, step into a higher leadership position, get paid for your ideas instead of the hours you put in at work, and enjoy more time, freedom, energy, and joy? Then you need to get your hands on a copy of Promotions Made Easy. Get your copy here.

What You'll Learn:

  • Why most cover letters instantly lost my interest - and the unexpected details that made me stop and say “YES”
  • Why one of my favorite interviews didn’t lead to a hire - and what she said that made me question guess everything
  • How one well-meaning comment instantly changed how I felt about a candidate
  • The follow-up approach that actually kept people top of mind long after the interview ended
  • Why a “no” from a hiring manager might not mean what you think it means

Listen to the Full Episode:

Featured on the Show:

official-bio-square

About Your Host

Hi! I'm Stacy Mayer, a Certified Executive Coach and Promotion Strategist on a mission to bring more diversity to the leadership table by getting 1000 underrepresented corporate managers promoted into senior executive positions each year worldwide.

I help undervalued executives scale to the C-Suite using repositioning strategies that build your confidence and visibility, so you can earn the recognition and support you need from key stakeholders while embodying your unique leadership style.

My podcast “Women Changing Leadership with Stacy Mayer” tackles topics like executive communication, getting more respect in the workplace from challenging bosses and team members, and avoiding the common mistakes that sabotage career advancement.

Enjoy the Show?

Please Share This:
You Might Also Like:
Blog art - The Promotion Strategy for Smart Women Who Think Differently

Ep #306: The Promotion Strategy for Smart Women Who Think Differently

Blog art - Reform Your Inner Mean Girl with Amy Ahlers

Ep #305: Reform Your Inner Mean Girl with Amy Ahlers

Blog art - Ep #304 5 Pieces of “Good” Career Advice That Cost You Promotions

Ep #304: 5 Pieces of “Good” Career Advice That Cost You Promotions